Facebook
X
Pinterest
Copy Link
Most homeowners thinking about selling their home focus on the sale price – understandably. That number is the headline, the thing you tell people, and the figure that feels like your reward for the years you've spent building equity. But the amount you walk away with after closing is a very different number, and in New York, the gap between what your home sells for and what you actually net can be surprising if you're not prepared.
Here is a complete, honest accounting of every cost you should anticipate as a seller in New York – not to discourage you from selling, but to ensure you go into the process with clear eyes and a realistic financial plan.
Real Estate Agent Commission
The largest single cost for most sellers is the real estate agent commission. Traditionally structured as 5% to 6% of the sale price and split between the listing agent and the buyer's agent, this fee is paid by the seller out of the proceeds at closing.
On a $700,000 sale at a 5% commission, that's $35,000. On a $900,000 sale at 5.5%, it's $49,500. These are significant numbers, and they should be factored into your planning before you list.
Recent changes in the real estate industry have introduced more transparency and some variation in how commissions are structured, but sellers should expect to account for both sides of the commission in their net proceeds calculation – the listing side (your agent's compensation) and the buyer's agent compensation, which you will typically need to offer to attract buyer's agents and their clients.
New York State Transfer Tax
New York State charges a transfer tax of $4 per $500 of the sale price (or 0.8%) on all residential real estate sales. This tax is paid by the seller.
On a $700,000 sale: $5,600. On a $900,000 sale: $7,200. This is a line item that many sellers don't know about until they review their closing documents.
The Mansion Tax – Paid by the Buyer, But It Affects You
While the New York State Mansion Tax (1% or more on purchases of $1 million or more) is technically paid by the buyer, sellers of homes in this price range need to understand that the mansion tax affects buyer purchasing calculations. Buyers factor this additional cost into their total purchase cost, which can affect what they're willing to offer. In markets where many transactions fall near the $1 million threshold, pricing strategy should account for this.
Additional Local Transfer Taxes
Some municipalities in New York impose additional local transfer taxes on top of the state tax. Sellers in certain incorporated villages or specific counties may find additional line items at closing that reflect local tax obligations. Your real estate attorney will identify these for your specific location, but budget for them as a possibility.
Real Estate Attorney Fee
New York requires a real estate attorney for residential sales, and the seller's attorney is paid from the sale proceeds at closing. Attorney fees for sellers in New York typically range from $1,500 to $3,500 depending on the complexity of the transaction and the attorney's billing structure. Co-op sales and transactions involving unusual circumstances tend to be at the higher end of this range.
This is not an area to economize aggressively. A real estate transaction in New York is a legal proceeding, and the attorney who handles your sale protects your interests throughout the contract and closing process.
Pre-Sale Repairs and Improvements
Before your home goes to market, you'll likely spend something on preparation. This might range from a few hundred dollars for fresh paint and deep cleaning to several thousand dollars for repairs identified during a pre-listing inspection or larger updates intended to maximize sale price.
Common pre-sale expenditures for New York sellers include interior painting ($2,000—$6,000 for most homes), professional cleaning ($300—$600), landscaping improvements ($500—$2,500), minor repairs and touch-ups ($500—$3,000), and in some cases larger items like roof repair or HVAC servicing that are advisable before buyers encounter them in inspection.
Budget these costs honestly as part of your selling expense, not separately from it.
Professional Photography and Marketing
Professional real estate photography typically costs $200 to $500 for a residential listing. Drone photography or videography adds to this cost. Virtual tours, 3D walkthroughs, and premium marketing materials are additional line items some sellers invest in for the right property.
If these costs are covered by your listing agent as part of their service, your out-of-pocket is zero. If not, they are a real cost worth knowing about in advance.
Home Staging
If professional staging is appropriate for your home – and for vacant homes or homes with dated furnishings, it often is – costs range from $1,500 to $6,000+ depending on the scope of the service. As covered in a previous post, the return on staging investment is typically well above the cost, but it is still a cost that leaves your pocket before closing.
Mortgage Payoff
If you have a remaining mortgage balance on your home, that balance is paid off at closing from the proceeds. This is not a "cost" in the traditional sense – it's the repayment of money you borrowed – but it dramatically affects your net proceeds and is sometimes overlooked in informal back-of-napkin calculations.
Additionally, some mortgages carry prepayment penalties for paying off the loan before a certain date. Review your mortgage documents or contact your lender to confirm whether this applies to you.
Prorated Property Taxes
In New York, property taxes are paid in arrears – meaning you pay this year's taxes sometime after they're incurred. At closing, sellers typically credit the buyer for the portion of the current tax year that has elapsed but for which taxes haven't yet been paid. Depending on timing, this credit can represent several thousand dollars.
Moving Expenses
Depending on your circumstances, moving out of the home you're selling involves real costs. Local moves in New York can cost $1,500 to $5,000+; long-distance moves or larger homes cost more. These costs don't appear on your closing statement but are part of the true financial picture of your home sale.
The Net Sheet: Your Financial Blueprint
The single best tool for understanding your true expected proceeds is a seller's net sheet – a document that lists all expected proceeds, costs, and credits to show what you will realistically walk away with at closing. A good listing agent prepares this for you before you list, based on your target sale price, current mortgage balance, and applicable costs.
Review this document carefully. Ask questions about any line item you don't understand. The goal is no surprises at closing.
I prepare a detailed net sheet for every seller I work with before they commit to listing, so that the financial reality of their sale is completely clear from day one. If you want to know what you'd actually walk away with from a sale of your New York home, I'll give you a straight answer. Call me at (321) 447-4259 or visit movewithricky.com.
Rakesh (Ricky) Khanna | Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Realty Connect
Call or text: (321) 447-4259 | movewithricky.com
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
